Skip to content

Welcome to our store

Shop all
Stickers
Magnets
Halloween
Wholesale
About

The Pig & Butterfly

Adulting Achievement Badges

Sarcastic & Snarky

Pop Culture & Nostalgia

Montana & the Hi-Line

Funny Zodiac

Halloween & Spooky Season

Holiday: Christmas & Hanukkah

Account

Pop Culture & Nostalgia

Movie quotes, 90s and Y2K nostalgia, and the references that made you who you are. For elder millennials and anyone who still misses rewinding the tape.

Skip to results list

Active filters:

21 items

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Active filters:

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Sold out

Heavily Influenced by 90s Movies Magnet

Heavily Influenced by 90s Movies Magnet

$7.00
Sold out

Jimothy, the Hero We Needed Magnet

Jimothy, the Hero We Needed Magnet

$7.00
Sold out

More Cow Bell Magnet

More Cow Bell Magnet

$7.00
I Cannot Live, Laugh, Love in These Conditions Magnet

I Cannot Live, Laugh, Love in These Conditions Magnet

$7.00
Do It For The Plot Sticker

Do It For The Plot Sticker

$5.00
Being Normal Denotes a Lack of Courage Magnet

Being Normal Denotes a Lack of Courage Magnet

$7.00
You Went 5,000 Kelvin, Carl Magnet

You Went 5,000 Kelvin, Carl Magnet

$7.00
Rewinding Was a Responsibility Magnet

Rewinding Was a Responsibility Magnet

$7.00
Say Perhaps to Drugs Magnet

Say Perhaps to Drugs Magnet

$7.00
More Cow Bell Sticker

More Cow Bell Sticker

$5.00
My Feelings Were Track 7 Sticker

My Feelings Were Track 7 Sticker

$5.00
Elder Millennial Sticker

Elder Millennial Sticker

$5.00
Rewinding Was a Responsibility Sticker

Rewinding Was a Responsibility Sticker

$5.00
You Went 5,000 Kelvin, Carl Sticker

You Went 5,000 Kelvin, Carl Sticker

$5.00
Heavily Influenced by 90s Movies Sticker

Heavily Influenced by 90s Movies Sticker

$5.00
Say Perhaps to Drugs Sticker

Say Perhaps to Drugs Sticker

$5.00
Jimothy, the Hero We Needed Sticker

Jimothy, the Hero We Needed Sticker

$5.00
Being Normal Denotes a Lack of Courage Sticker

Being Normal Denotes a Lack of Courage Sticker

$5.00
I Cannot Live, Laugh, Love in These Conditions Sticker

I Cannot Live, Laugh, Love in These Conditions Sticker

$5.00
Piper! Nooooo! Sticker

Piper! Nooooo! Sticker

$5.00
This Is Going to Ruin the Tour Sticker

This Is Going to Ruin the Tour Sticker

$5.00

Join our email list

Get exclusive deals and early access to new products.

Email

© 2026 The Pig & Butterfly, Powered by Shopify

Privacy policy
Refund policy
Terms of service
Contact information

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Search

Search

Products

A Little Dead Inside Magnet

A Little Dead Inside Magnet

$7.00
A Little Dead Inside Sticker

A Little Dead Inside Sticker

$5.00
A Woman's Place Is In The Coven Sticker

A Woman's Place Is In The Coven Sticker

$5.00
Actually Used a Coupon Sticker

Actually Used a Coupon Sticker

$5.00